Description
Activities
|
Moroccan Jewry and its Dispersions
Gathering from
November 2, 2005
January 18, 2006
|
Topic: |
Moroccan
Jewry and
its
Dispersions
|
|
Presentation
of the
Report's
Findings |
Prof. Sergio
DellaPergola
|
|
Respondents: |
HaRishon LeZion, the Chief Rabbi of Israel, Rabbi
Shlomo Amar
Dr. Hayim
Saadon –
Hebrew
University
Dr. Moshe
Amar –
Bar-Ilan
University
Prof. Shimon
Shetreet –
Hebrew
University
Mr. André
Azoulay –
Advisor to
the King of
Morocco,
Muhammad VI
Mr. Robert
Asraf – the
World
Federation
of Moroccan
Jewry
Mr. Serge
Berdugo –
the
Chairperson
of the
Moroccan
Jewish
Community |
|
Closing
Remarks: |
The Honorable President of the State of
Israel, Mr.
Moshe Katzav
|
The
Chief Rabbi – Rabbi Shlomo Amar
I heard an interesting
interpretation from a friend for the proverb “He
that spareth his rod [shivto] hateth his
son,” which goes well beyond the accepted meaning: a
person that does not tell his son about his tribe
[the Hebrew word for tribe and rod are the same],
hates him, for he fails to provide the child with
the basis he needs to grow and flourish.
This
assembly is dedicated to the true tradition of the
tribe—a tradition that we Moroccan Jews have upheld
for generations, by dint of our ancestors who bore
the exile with dignity and genius, withstood all the
challenges, studied Torah, and observed all the
commandments. Just as Moshe rabainu [our
rabbi] grasped on to the throne of the Holy One
blessed be He and did not recoil from the
ministering angels, we too held on to our faith in
Hashem and our forefathers’ traditions. Our
heritage endowed us with the strength to withstand
all our enemies, as well as all our lovers, who
sought to steer us off our path.
Moroccan
Jewry benefited from great Torah sages in all the
fields of Torah study: Halachic jurisprudence,
commentary, Talmudic scholarship, liturgical hymns,
etc. Therefore, many libraries are brimming with the
wisdom of Morocco’s scholars. Every city and region
merited its own scholars. Morocco is a spacious
land, and its metropolises are not only quite a
distance from each other, but vastly different as
well—to the point where each city is akin to a
separate country. However, despite the heterogeneity
and contrasts, there was cross-fertilization between
the various communities.
Besides
for their Torah prowess, Morocco’s sages also
mastered the corpus of general knowledge, and their
reputation thus spread throughout the world. That
said, the periods in which we pursued other
interests were, by the grace of God, fleeting. The
shift away from our roots was connected to our
aliyah to Israel and our dispersal to other
lands. However, within a short time, we returned to
quarry from our own mines, from the traditions that
our forefathers had passed down from generation to
generation.
Now that we
are reacquainting ourselves with the legacy of our
forefathers, we must remember that this is the same
holy Torah that was at the disposal of our
forefathers, without which we have no hope of
sustaining ourselves. It is the Torah that provides
the light and by virtue of which we exist. For
generations, it served as a mobile motherland that
bore us on its shoulders through thick and thin. It
is our duty to imbue our children and grandchildren
with love for the Torah, so that they will not,
heavens forbid, distance themselves in their desire
to be too modern.
The bond to
the Land of Israel fortifies us and provides hope
for the coming generations as well. The Land of
Israel was given to us by dint of the Torah of
Israel. A person that does not recognize the virtues
of our land will draw closer by studying Torah.
Indeed, the Torah has served as a common thread that
has linked one generation to the next. Before the
advent of faxes, telephones, and other means of
communication, it connected the entire Jewish people
regardless of where they dwelt, even those living in
the most remote corners of the Earth; by dint of its
very holiness, it united and drew Jews together. We
will continue to grasp on to the Torah, and the
Torah will continue to illuminate our path.
I would
like to thank the President and all the organizers
for initiating this commendable enterprise. May it
be the will of the Almighty that this gathering
shall be for the sake of the heavens—may it bolster
the unity and brotherhood amongst all the
communities of Israel. By virtue of this endeavor,
may we soon hear the call of the Messiah’s shofar
proclaiming the redemption and salvation in our
own lifetime. Amen.
Dr.
Hayim Saadon
Dr. Saadon opens his
lecture by mentioning two successful plays in
Jewish-Moroccan Arabic that are running at
al-Maghreb Theater in Israel. The success of these
plays is indicative of the transformation that
Israel’s Moroccan expatriates have undergone within
the course of a generation. If this community once
tended to downplay its roots, Moroccan heritage is
now openly embraced and a source of pride. Another
salient example of this phenomenon is the
publication of two books: The Biblical Commentary
of Rabbi Rafael Berdugo by the Israel Prize
laureate, Prof. Moshe Bar-Asher, (5762/2002)
and The Traditional Jewish Wedding in Morocco
by Prof. Yosef Shetreet (5763/2003).
Dr. Saadon
then reveals the title of his lecture, “Morocco’s
Jews Forge their Historical Memory,” and enumerates
the four fundamental developments that influenced
Moroccan Jewry during the twentieth century and
crafted their identity in their expatriate
communities. In the second part of the speech, the
lecturer will discuss how Moroccan Jews are
contending with their past and the identities that
are taking shape in the current centers of Moroccan
Jewish life.
The first of
the four developments is the cultural changes that
Moroccan Jews have undergone over the past century.
In 1912, French culture was added to the Arab,
Berber, and Spanish influences. Zionist and to some
extent Marxist ideologies also had an impact. A
French culture ultimately emerged from this panoply
of factors that is quite different from the culture
in France or other francophone regions in the world.
The second
development is the demographic changes that Moroccan
Jewry underwent, the most prominent of which was the
community’s rapid growth. At the beginning of the
twentieth century, there were about 100,000 Jews in
Morocco, but by the eve of the War of Independence
there were nearly 280,000. This ascent turned
Morocco into the home of the largest Jewish
community in the Muslim world. There were also major
changes in all that concerned the distribution of
the Jewish population within the country, as Jews
relocated en masse. In the process, they
dramatically altered their lifestyles as well. For
example, the city of Casablanca jumped from 5,000
Jews at around the turn of the century to 85,000 in
1961, and Rabat’s community rose from 2,000 Jews to
13,000 in 1951. Alternatively, many Jews left the
country altogether: 110,000 made aliyah
(moved to Israel) from 1947 to 1957 and left behind
what was still a sizeable population of 200,000
Jews. Another 20,000 settled in Israel between 1957
and 1962. Thereafter, the flood gates burst open, as
another 100,000 Jews moved to Israel over the next
two years. Unlike the traumatic waves of aliyah
during the 1950s, the aliyah of the early
1960s was absorbed in a relatively smooth manner.
Yet another mass exodus after the Six-Day War
rendered the previously fertile community into a
small outpost of Jewish life. Although there is a
tendency to generalize and refer to all those who
emigrated from the country ‘Moroccan Jews,’ this
mass of humanity is, in fact, extremely diverse.
This broad definition encompasses various identities
and cultures that were profoundly influenced by
their particular communities and geographic regions
within Morocco.
The third
development is the special relationship between the
Jewish community and the King of Morocco, which
intensified during the French cultural invasion and
all the more so following Moroccan independence. In
fact, the relationship strengthened after most of
the community had already departed. Moreover, the
monarchy’s relations with the Israeli government and
security factors added an especially unique
dimension to these relations. In his memoirs, Meir
Amit, the former head of the Mossad provides a
moving testimony on the extent of the relationship
between Israel and the Moroccan monarchy. For
example, Amit described the large delegation from
Israel that paid its respects at the funeral of King
Hasan II. All Jewish Moroccan expatriates share
similar sentiments with respect to the monarchy.
The fourth
development is the veneration of holy figures, both
within and outside of Morocco. Distinguished
researchers (Dr. Yisachar Ben Amir, Prof. Yoram
Bilu, and others) have examined this phenomenon and
its evident contradiction with modernity. This
unique phenomenon has expanded in Israel, where,
besides for the religious dimension, it has also
taken on economic and political significance.
Of all
the dispersions of Moroccan Jewry (Israel, France,
Canada, Spain, and South America), the most
prominent community is in Israel. The integration
process of Moroccan Jews into Israeli society will
not be discussed in detail herein. However, it must
be noted that the absorption of Moroccan Jews during
the 1950s is perceived in the Israeli consciousness
as a most trying enterprise. At the time, the
political and social establishment feared that their
integration would orientalize Israeli society,
especially given the relatively high number of
potential Moroccan olim (immigrants to
Israel) vis à vis the size of the yishuv
(the Jewish community in Israel before the
establishment of the state). No wonder, then, that
negative stereotypes evolved, which formed a
psychological barrier between Moroccan Jewry and
Israeli society. The quintessential example of these
fears was the encounter between the Jews from north
Africa and Europe that were caught trying to slip
into the yishuv with the help of the
ma’apilim (a force that smuggled Jews past naval
blockades and into Israel) at the detention camps in
Cypress.
Other
examples of this tension include Aryeh Gelblum’s
known article in Haaretz in April 1949
(wherein he claimed that the Moroccan olim
were primitive), the aliyah selection
criteria, and Wadi Saliv (Moroccan riots in Haifa in
1956). The differences between Ashkenazim and
Sephardim and terms such as ‘ethnic gap’ were
prevalent features of the integration of Morocco’s
Jews into Israeli society.
However, today—in this the second generation since
Israel’s independence— a profound change has begun
to take place in the attitude towards the Moroccan
expatriates. For example, the “Song of Requests” and
Memunah Festivities have become accepted parts of
the Israeli calendar and holiday culture. The
representation of Moroccan Jews in the institutions
of government has increased and the importance of
ones origin has diminished. Overall, the stereotypes
that informed the country’s first years are steadily
dissipating. The activities of Moroccan expatriate
organizations in Israel have played a role in all
these developments. These groups have not only
sought to change the old image, but to shape the
community’s historical memory as well.
There
are several focal points of remembrance. Foremost
among them is the official commemoration of the day
on which the Egoz, a ma’apilim ship, sank in
1961 as Ha’apala from Morocco Day. A public
committee has been established for this purpose and
several activities have been undertaken to mark the
tragedy: some of the remains of the dead have been
brought to Israel and buried on Mount Herzl;
ceremonies are held every year in Jerusalem and
Ashdod; and television programs and musicals have
been produced on the Egoz.
The Egoz has
thus become a part of the Israeli ethos.
Unfortunately, according to Dr. Saadon, the story is
not backed by sufficient historical research and
there are substantial discrepancies between the
various versions of the affair. This is not the
first time a focal point of remembrance that has not
been verified by means of scientific research has
determined what is widely believed to be the
historical facts. The archives on the topic have yet
to be opened, and the public record is primarily
comprised of private testimonies. Let us hope that
the research currently being conducted will
determine the facts behind the Egoz affair once and
for all.
Another
center of consciousness is the above-mentioned
Memunah. Although the exact origins are a matter for
debate, Moroccan Jews would celebrate the day after
Passover with an array of foods and costumes. This
annual warm gesture was named the Memunah, and
Moroccan expatriate communities continue to
celebrate this holiday. Since the 1960s, the Memunah
has turned into a public event that attracts the
leaders of Israeli society. Every year the
celebrations seem to take on a more national airs,
as the event is celebrated by wide swathes of the
general public, albeit with the original Moroccan
symbols of the holiday: food, attire, and music. The
Memunah has even become an accepted day off from
work. Similar holidays of other communities have
neither reverberated throughout Israeli society nor
enjoyed the same success as the Memunah.
Moroccan
Jewish organizations that endeavor to forge the
community’s collective memory have, inter alia,
renewed the tradition of the Song of Requests and
have founded centers that are devoted to
Moroccan-Jewish hymns (not to mention the Andalusia
Symphony). Similar activities have also been
undertaken in other centers of the Moroccan-Jewish
dispersion.
The
very process of shaping the public memory is most
beneficial. Other communities can learn from the
enterprise of Moroccan Jews, which has proven that
once traditions and events have undergone a process
of natural selection—whereby they are pared down to
their most acceptable, popular elements—Israeli
culture will eventually absorb them all.
To conclude,
the lecturer offers to change the name of his
lecture to “The Secret behind Moroccan Charm.”
Dr.
Moshe Amar
I have been asked to
compare the institution of the rabbinate in Morocco
to its counterpart in Israel. The Chief Rabbinate in
Israel was established in 1921 by the British
Mandate. Its authority was limited to the laws of
matrimony (marriage and divorce) and was subordinate
to Mandatory and subsequently Israeli law. In
Morocco, the rabbinate was founded in 1918, and this
marked the first time that a chief rabbi would serve
all the Jews of Morocco. The appointee also served
as the nasi (chief justice) of the Rabbinic
High Court of Appeals. Rav Rephael Alkava of
blessed memory was the first chief rabbi of Morocco.
In a country
as vast as Morocco, the distances and transportation
difficulties gave rise to disparate traditions of
jurisprudence, as various regions adopted their own
unique customs. However, with the improvement in
communications during the French Mandate, the
differences started to stick out and questions and
perplexities arose: Which customs—for example,
kashrut or inheritance law—should be binding on the
entire community? Since their were no longer
isolated communities—in fact, the opposite was the
case, as there was extensive contact between the
various communities, much of which was quite
intimate—there was a need to bridge the Halachic
differences Yet another serious problem that
Moroccan Jewry was confronted with was the forces of
secularization, which were undermining Jewish
tradition. The French introduced secularization to
Morocco in the late nineteenth century and it
continued to influence the country throughout the
course of the twentieth century.
In
response to these urgent problems, the rabbinic
leadership decided to call a rabbinical conference,
and six such conventions were held between 1947 and
1956. Although they dealt with highly contentious
issues, the leaders organized the conferences and
established guidelines in a manner that guaranteed
their success. For example, a very limited amount of
time was allotted to each subject, as the rabbis
realized that the discussions and negotiations
themselves would not lead to solutions. Instead, all
the participants received the topics in advance and
did their homework, so that the primary objective of
the assembly was not to discuss the issues, but to
decide on them by means of a majority vote in
a public show of hands. Rabbi Shaul Ibn Danan, the
deputy chief rabbi (who later served as the chief
rabbi) told the delegates that this sort of
framework had been in place since the destruction of
the Temple. Indeed, the Torah authorizes the
scholars of each generation to adjudicate reforms
and this applies to the present generation as well.
The rabbis are thus prohibited from shirking away
from responsibility and weaseling their way out of
ruling on the pressing matters of the day.
Accordingly, it is thus clear that claims such as
“What will the fanatics say” or “We have less
authority than the first generations” don’t hold
water.
Of the many
topics that were discussed at these rabbinical
conferences, I would like to focus on two problems
that the rabbis in Morocco indeed managed to
resolve, but which in Israel have continued to
linger on for years with no end in sight. The first
topic is the inheritance laws in Morocco. At the
time, three different customs were in practice: the
Marrakesh region acted strictly in accordance to
Halacha; the Spanish region adhered to the customs
of the Jewish exiles from Spain; and in Paz, Rabbi
Raphael Berdugo’s rules were added to the reforms of
the Spanish exiles.
The rabbis
then formulated a code that would apply to all of
Morocco’s Jews, but the delegates nonetheless had
qualms about revising traditions that had been
practiced for five hundred years. Heeding Rabbi
Danan’s advice, the rabbis decided to conduct a
country-wide survey, and most of the communities
agreed to accept their reform. Correspondingly, the
Ashkenazic Chief Rabbi of Israel, Isaac Herzog, sat
together with his Sephardic counterpart, Rabbi
Uziel, and mooted over the same exact issue for
years. The two wrote countless articles on the
matter, but ultimately failed to reform the
inheritance laws—apparently due to their trepidation
of the fanatics.
The
conferences also dealt with the matter of kashrut.
Until that time, when a Moroccan Jew traveled to
another community, he deliberated long and hard over
whether he could eat the food, especially the meat.
The solution that they found was both simple and
interesting. Notwithstanding the manifold customs,
everyone agreed that there was one tradition that
could be substantiated: the kashrut in the city of
Meknes, where interpretations had been written for
generations by the rabbis of the Berdugo family.
Consequently, the Meknes tradition appeared to be
well-grounded, and the delegates proposed adopting
it as the law of the land. However, since the rabbis
were sensitive about hurting the feelings of the
other communities, they established a special
committee of rabbis which conducted an in-depth
study of the various kashrut customs. The committee
found that there were 23 discrepancies between the
customs. Thereafter, they examined each difference
and searched for the custom that was most grounded
in Halacha. After two years, the committee
unanimously agreed upon a new kashrut code that
would apply to the entire community—from the simple
Jew to the most stringent observer.
I would now
like to turn our attention to yet another topic that
remains relevant to this day and age: the phenomenon
of hilulot (veneration ceremonies) at the
graves of the righteous. In both Israel and Morocco,
this phenomenon only reached its present magnitude
during the 1950s. Due to the rise in the number of
hilulot, the matter was raised before the
Moroccan Rabbinical Council. The rabbis ruled that
they had no choice but to countenance those
hilulot that already existed. However, from
thereon in the entire matter would be placed under
the supervision of the Council, and anyone wishing
to add a new hilula must receive the approval
of the Rabbinical High Court in Morocco along with
the consent of the chief rabbi. Since the decision
was passed, not one hilula has been added. In
my opinion, this episode testifies to the fact that
the rabbis of Morocco were men that led and not men
that were led. Regretfully, here in Israel a new
saint is proclaimed on a daily basis, whereas in
Morocco the rabbis in Morocco urged their flock “not
to call these ceremonies hilulim
(venerations) but chilulim (denigrations).”
In sum, from
the expulsion of Spain in 1492 until 1956, the
rabbis of Morocco took advantage of reforms in order
to solve their problems. As far as we know, the
reforms of the Moroccan Rabbinic Council are the
last to be enacted in the communities of Israel.
These reforms prove that the scholars of Morocco
dwelled amongst their flock. Despite the holes that
the onset of modernity had pierced in the armor of
Jewish tradition, these men didn’t try to shirk away
from responsibility and initiated discussions on
these very problems. Whereupon they passed utile
reforms within the framework of Halacha, before the
public even had a chance to devise its own solutions
in a manner that would perhaps contradict the
Halacha.
The
Rabbinical Council in Morocco is an exemplary
example of a rabbinic institution that had the
wherewithal to cope with the challenges of modern
life. Their discussions and reforms enabled them to
find solutions for every problem they encountered
within the framework of the Halacha and Hebrew law.
Israel’s rabbinate has much to learn from the
sagacious rabbis of Morocco.
Prof.
Shimon Shetreet
Prof. Shetreet commences
his words with warm greetings to the guests: Mr.
André Azoulay, King Muhammad VI’s advisor, who left
a thriving personal business in order to take on a
royal mission; to Mr. Serge Berdugo the chairperson
of the community and the former minister of tourism,
whose endeavors earned him the king’s Seal of
Excellence; to Mr. Robert Asraf, who besides for
filling top-ranking government posts donated a chair
to the Hebrew University in Jerusalem.
The topic of
his lecture is the contribution of Moroccan Jewry to
Israeli society and democracy, with a look back at
the past while keeping an eye on the future. Prof
Shetreet made aliyah with his family in 1949,
when he was three years old. Most of Moroccan Jewry
rose to the occasion, fulfilled the mitzvah
(biblical commandment) of Zionism, and made
aliyah. Members of the community can be counted
among the pillars of Israeli society. Many of these
builders and contributors are in the audience:
rabbis, scholars, military officers, business
people, public figures, professors, and farmers.
Included among them are also members of the north
African, Zionist underground, whose praiseworthy
efforts set the stage for the arrival of these
Diasporas to Israel. Today, Israel’s Moroccan
community consists of over 600,000 members.
Throughout its history, Moroccan Jewry has
preserved its bond to the Land of Israel. Community
members also made aliyah long before the
establishment of the state—for example, Rabbi Chaim
Ben-Attar in the eighteenth century or Rabbi Ya’acov
Abu-Chatzairah, who died on route to Zion. The
Shlush, Amzaleg, and Moyal families were already on
hand to welcome the arrival of the BILU pioneers (a
Zionist movement founded in Russia, whose members
first reached the Promised Land in 1882). In
addition, these Moroccan families were among the
founders of Achuzat Bayit (the association
that founded the first neighborhood in Tel-Aviv),
and quite a few of them were also ma’apilim.
The illegal aliyah would continue until the
tragic sinking of the Egoz in January
1961(forty-four people lost their lives in that
terrible disaster), after which the gates of legal
immigration from Morocco were opened. Thanks to the
intervention of Prof. Shetreet, the late Yitzchak
Rabin of blessed memory instructed the Mossad to
submit its confidential report on the Egoz affair to
the bereaved families.
Today, many
Moroccan-Jewish expatriates and their progeny, who
were born outside of Morocco, visit the country.
These visits have become a unique and deeply moving
event. It constitutes a link to their personal past
that also taps into the history of the entire Jewish
people. Jews of Moroccan descent must bear the
responsibility for documenting and collecting the
cultural treasures that have been left behind in
Morocco, where the Jews enjoyed much cultural and
economic autonomy. This endeavor is especially
important in light of the fact that throughout most
of its history the people of Morocco—Muslims and
Jews alike—managed to uphold a culture of peace.
This is
the moment to commend Mr. Chaim Cohen for his
beautiful exhibit in the Knesset on the central
figures of Morocco’s Jewish community. He also
wishes to thank the Association of Moroccan
Organizations in Israel, under the leadership of
Yizhak Eshel, for the support that they provide to
scholars researching the field of Moroccan Jewry.
Prof. Shetreet underscores the studies that have
been conducted on the aliyah of the
Mughrabim (Jews from the Maghreb that came to
Israel in the mid-nineteenth century) and the
settlement of the “new aliyah” between 1943
and 1964. In fact, the members of the new aliyah
were responsible for the founding of 115 moshavim
(cooperative agricultural villages), 15
kibbutzim, and 20 new towns in Israel.
Furthermore,
the Committee of the Sephardic Community—the most
venerable of the north African expatriate
organizations—the World Center for the Heritage of
North African Jewry, BeYachad, the World Federation
of Moroccan Jews, and other organizations, which
represent specific cities of origin, sectors, etc,
all deserve to be extolled on account of their
endeavors to preserve the cultural legacy of
Moroccan Jewry.
Prof.
Shetreet reiterates the fact that his accolades
apply to all the organizations that are involved in
this enterprise—including those that were not
specifically mentioned—but he admits that there are
too many organizations. The lecturer thus turns to
President Katzav who perhaps by virtue of his wisdom
will manage to help these groups transform into one,
unified, and united organization, so that we will
not be a Babylon, but as stated in Genesis and
Ezekiel will “become of one flesh” or “one tree
trunk.”
Mr.
André Azoulay, Advisor to King Muhammad VI of
Morocco
I will speak from the
heart about what I truly feel. First and foremost, I
would like to thank President Katzav for making this
evening possible. For me, as both a Moroccan Jew and
Jewish Moroccan, this is indeed an historic occasion
in the annals of Moroccan Jewry, for it marks the
realization of a dream that all Jews of Moroccan
descent have harbored for some thirty or forty
years:
During these
same years, it wasn’t easy for Moroccan Jews in
Israel and other countries to bear the derisive
glances and attitudes that evinced both ignorance
and prejudice. These were years in which members of
our community changed their names and concealed
their true place of birth. It is indeed a tragedy
when a person severs himself from his own heritage.
In contrast, the prevailing trend today is to take
pride in one’s Moroccan roots, but we mustn’t forget
the recent past. The shift stems from our obdurate
persistence to uphold the traditions of Moroccan
Jewry. This effort has not been undertaken out of a
sense of obligation to someone else, but stems from
an internal feeling and need. We sensed that this
was the way to reach a state of equilibrium and
secure our happiness. Therefore, the turnaround is
the victory of those Moroccan Jews who unequivocally
rejected the tempting options of forgetting or
denial.
The decision
to preserve the values of Moroccan-Jewish heritage
for ourselves and the coming generations obligates
Israel’s Moroccan community to place all these same
values at the disposal of Israel’s most vital
interests—security and peace with all your
neighbors—for to be a Moroccan means to take action
on behalf of peace. The education that we received
from our parents, teachers, and rabbis instilled in
us the importance of respecting our neighbors, who
were usually Muslims. We were taught that all
Moroccans are entitled to freedom, justice,
happiness, and security and that both Muslims and
Jews are endowed with dignity. Already as a child, I
demonstrated on behalf of Morocco’s independence,
for this was the message that I received from my
forefathers and rabbis. As peace mongers, Morocco’s
Jews wish to do everything in our power to promote
meetings between Israelis and Palestinians, while
preserving the dignity of both sides. As Jews living
in a Muslim country, it is indeed incumbent upon us
to do everything we can for the sake of the peace
process. The words that I express before both Jewish
and Muslim or Arab audiences are one and the same.
We Moroccans are part of a culture that is thousands
of years old. This culture developed in the East in
the same expanse in which Islam took form, and the
Moroccan Jews have always been a part of this world.
A process
began some fifty years ago that dispersed Morocco’s
Jews throughout the far corners of the earth—to
Israel and other countries—and left but a handful of
Jews in the country. However, the detachment from
the expanse in which this community developed was
not the end of the line, but the beginning of a new
road. Moroccan Jewry is destined to cultivate its
memory in joy and happiness. Even if we have endured
periods of hardship and suffering, our history lacks
the tragic stories of other communities. Moroccan
Jews did not experience the litany of persecutions
and murders that others went through. Therefore, the
relative harmony that informs the history of
Moroccan Jewry is nothing to be scoffed at. We have
enjoyed special relations with our neighbors, who,
for the most part, have understood us and protected
the Jewish community in times of need.
Over the
past fifty years, the Jews in this Muslim country
heard about every incident in which a Jew or Israeli
was killed by an Arab or Muslim and in which a
Palestinian or Arab was harmed by a Jew. It is not
easy to live as a Jew in a Muslim country when these
sorts of events transpire. The kings of Morocco have
made quite an effort to transform the relations
between Israel and the Arab world. Against this
backdrop, Morocco’s Jews have done whatever they
possibly can to initiate and advance the peace
process. Today, it is incumbent upon Moroccan Jews,
wherever they may be, to assume an ideological stand
that will serve the cause of peace.
In the
presence of the Rishon LeZion [chief
Sephardic rabbi], I am honored to point out the
pride that Morocco’s Jews take in the rabbis that
have shepherded our communities over the
generations—even if this topic has yet to merit the
attention it deserves. I truly hope that other Jews
will also learn about and recognize the
contributions of these wise rabbis.
May the
next generations—our children and grandchildren—also
experience the joy of learning from Moroccan Jewry
and realizing what a privilege it is to be a
Moroccan Jew. Finally, may the legacy of Moroccan
Jewry be as much a part of them as it is a part of
us.
Mr.
Robert Asraf
To begin with, I thank
President Katzav and the participants for their
gracious hospitality.
For
what is now ten years, I have run the Center for the
Study of Moroccan-Jewish History. In 1948, there
were some 250,000 to 280,000 Jews in Morocco;
between 1945 and 1950, 34,000 made aliyah;
and another 86,000 settled in Israel from 1953 to
1956, in the aftermath of King Muhammad V’s exile to
Madagascar. In the early 1960s, after Hasan II had
already assumed the throne, my hands-on cooperation
with the authorities enabled 100,000 more Jews to
make aliyah. Nearly a quarter million
Moroccan Jews eventually immigrated to Israel, which
for all intents and purposes constituted practically
the entire community (as much as 90%). The reason
that so many Moroccan Jews left for Israel is that
the community has always been connected to the
Jewish faith as well as the Jewish people. Our pride
in our Moroccan roots has accompanied us to
Israel and every other venue that we have reached
(France, Canada, etc.).
In my
opinion, there are at most 3,000 Jews left in
Morocco. Those that remain essentially live in both
Morocco and France, to include the community’s
leaders.
For
generations, the Jewish nation has preserved its
religion on its own, and our relationship with God
is direct and unmediated. These attributes will
continue to inform this relationship in the future.
We are
a nation that strives for peace. For years the
community has stated that we are waiting for the
Arabs, including the Moroccans, to recognize the
State of Israel and then we too would reciprocate by
recognizing the State of Palestine.
Mr.
Serge Berdugo
Mr. Berdugo opens his
speech by commending the president on his
initiative. He then makes note of the festive
occasion that was held the day before in the
Knesset—the opening of an exhibit on the central
figures in the history of Moroccan Jewry. Above all,
he is glad to see that Moroccan Jewry is steadily
securing its rightful place in the State of Israel.
Morocco’s Jewish community is gradually rebuilding
itself in the aftermath of the mass exodus, as no
more than 5,000 Jews remain out of a community that
once boasted 280,000 members. The community’s
leaders, and especially its women, have made quite
an effort to revive Jewish life in Morocco. In 1977,
contact with the rest of the Jewish world was
restored following a decade of efforts. Since the
community’s establishment, it has borne a
two-pronged mission: to be both loyal Moroccans and
loyal Jews. The community has indeed managed to
fulfill both of these tasks.
Moroccan
Jewry is one of the few active Jewish communities in
the Muslim world. Today, there are some thirty
synagogues and three schools, with a total of about
3,000 children. All of the pupils that take the
matriculation examinations earn their diplomas. Last
year, the community hosted about 5,000 visitors. In
addition, three dayanim (rabbinical judges)
were qualified to adjudicate over all pertinent
matters.
Unfortunately, due to Morocco’s poverty and
unemployment, it is susceptible to the scourges of
fundamentalism and terror. This became starkly
evident on May 23, 2000, when three attacks were
launched against Jewish sites. Luckily, there were
no casualties, and the local population reacted
quickly, as over one million people marched in
protest of the attacks. Additionally, the king paid
a visit to the community and promised to protect its
members and their property. The community thus feels
that the authorities are looking out for its well
being, to the same degree to which they tend to the
needs of the rest of the country’s citizens.
Morocco’s
Jewish community has made the preservation of its
assets, which the members gradually built up over
the generations, a prime objective, and several
synagogues and cemeteries have already been
renovated. Similarly, a Jewish museum has been
inaugurated in Casablanca, which is open to the
general public. All its visitors learn about the
existence of another, non-Muslim Morocco. There are
also radio programs, websites, and bibliographical
publications on the community. Naturally, the entire
preservation enterprise requires the support of
Moroccan Jews throughout the world.
Morocco’s
Jews wish to contribute their share to the peace
process in the Middle East, In fact, they have
persistently pursued this course, without fanfare,
since 1984, as they have been involved in and
encouraged every possible meeting between Israelis
and Palestinians. All this has been made possible on
account of the welcomed efforts of Morocco’s
kings—Hasan II in his time and Muhammad VI today—and
its people. Even if the Moroccans support the
Palestinians’ demands, they understand that Israel
requires guarantees in order to exist in peace and
security.
Despite the
misleading images, the speaker has no doubt that
Moroccan Jews in Israel and the world over will help
reconcile the differences between Israelis and
Palestinians. This is a small community whose
importance transcends its mere size.
Morocco’s Jews are intimately connected to its
dispersions and proud of their achievements. The
hearts of all Moroccan Jews beat as one regardless
of where they may be.
Mr.
Berdugo thus considers the Moroccan Jewish community
a symbol of hope and reconciliation between all the
progeny of Abraham.
The
honorable president of Israel, Mr. Moshe Katzav
Closing Remarks
After hosting meetings
on other Jewish communities, such as the United
States, South America, and France, President Katzav
was truly excited about holding this forum on
Moroccan Jewry.
Moroccan Jewry maintained a close bond to the Land
of Israel for generations—well before the
establishment of the state. It is a community with
values and achievements, and its spiritual
contribution stands out in all fields of human
endeavor. This community also made a substantial
contribution to the construction of Israel and its
great achievements. Since its arrival, its
enterprise is evident throughout the State of
Israel, from Metullah to Eilat. Moroccan Jewry is a
thus a full-fledged partner in humanity’s
greatest achievement of the twentieth century: the
establishment and development of the State of
Israel. The community’s descendants as well as many
others will long remember Moroccan Jewry’s unique
contribution to all facets of Israeli life.
The
president does not intend upon merely reminiscing
about the past—on the community’s achievements,
history, legacy, and contribution to the
construction of the country, as well as the research
on the history of Moroccan Jewry in Morocco, Israel,
and its dispersions, or on recalling the
difficulties absorbing the Moroccan olim and
the illegal aliyah. Instead, President Katzav
will also turn his attention to the question of how
to shape the image of Moroccan Jewry in the coming
future and in the next fifty to a hundred years.
Besides for the heritage that is shared by the
entire Jewish people, it is imperative that the
leadership of the Moroccan community safeguard and
preserve its unique legacy, so that it can bequeath
it to the next generations. In light of the negative
processes besetting the Jewish people, we will, for
the most part, only be able to uphold our tradition
here in the State of Israel. Moroccan Jews are not
immune to these phenomena. It is worth remembering
that two-thirds of all Jewish children in the United
States do not receive a Jewish education. This
laxity is also liable to harm those Moroccan Jews
that are dispersed throughout the world. Therefore,
the leadership of Moroccan Jewry must take
responsibility over this vital issue.
Moroccan
Jewry also contributed to the creation of a culture
that was shared by Jew and Muslim alike. The kings
of Morocco also deserve to be praised for helping
the Jewish community develop over the years.
President Katzav wishes to personally extol the
contribution of King Hasan II of blessed memory. For
their part, Morocco’s Jews supported the Istiqlal
movement in its struggle for independence. Likewise,
the president wishes to commend the present king,
Muhammad VI, for protecting the Jewish community and
condemning anti-Semitism.
For
historical reasons and in light of the shared
interests of the two countries, the president hopes
that diplomatic relations with Morocco will soon be
renewed. Consequently, President Katzav would like
to take this opportunity to forward the king of
Morocco an invitation to visit Israel through the
good offices of the king’s talented advisor, Mr.
André Azoulay.
On
account of Mr. Azoulay’s words, the president would
also like to refer to the conflict with the
Palestinians. Over the past twelve years, the State
of Israel has orchestrated an historic turnaround in
its attitude towards the Palestinians. Therefore, in
the president’s opinion, it appears as if the
Muslim, Arab, and Palestinian worlds do not
appreciate the significance of these changes, for at
this very moment Qassam rockets are unfortunately
falling on Israel…
This
historic shift can roughly be broken down into three
seminal events. The first was the decision to sign
the Oslo Accords and the historic handshake that
ensued between Yitzchak Rabin and Yasser Arafat on
the White House lawn. The second event transpired
three years ago in the Knesset, when the Israeli
government decided to support the establishment of a
Palestinian state. Who in the Arab world would have
thought that this was at all possible twenty or even
ten years ago?
The
third event, which was of utmost importance, was the
withdrawal of 25 Jewish settlements in the Gaza
Strip. This measure has caused a deep rift and great
pain in Israeli society. Therefore, we expected a
different reaction from the Palestinians than the
launching of Qassam rockets and terror attacks; in
fact, eight Israelis were killed just this past
week.
Despite
the exceedingly horrible relations between the
Palestinian Authority and Israel, the president
believes that today the political differences
between the two sides are smaller than ever.
Consequently, there is an historic opportunity to
bridge these gaps and bring about reconciliation and
peace. It is only fitting that the Palestinian
leadership should prove its seriousness by
reciprocating Israel’s efforts at rapprochement with
but the smallest first step. The president believes
that Abu Mazen is an honest man and a partner.
Therefore, he hopes to meet with him soon in the
President’s Residence. Neither side can expect to
attain 100% of its demands, or realize all its
dreams. Each party will have to make certain
compromises, but our concessions must be accompanied
by concessions on their part as well. Against this
backdrop, a visit on the part of King Muhammad VI
can foster an atmosphere that will engender a
breakthrough.
The
president thanks all those who have come and all the
lecturers for their impressive speeches. He
concludes by expressing his hope that this gathering
will contribute to the continued realization of the
processes that are so essential to us all.
|